Author(s): Sarah Abbas
Mentor(s): Taylor Hartwell, ACE
Hello everyone, my name is Sarah Abbas. I am an undergraduate student pursuing an accelerated master’s degree in conflict resolution and analysis, with a concentration in law and justice
Today I will share a little bit about the preliminary research work that I have done for an ongoing investigation of mine regarding the nature of relationships between correctional officers and Inmates
My Research
This Summer I have been using an existing qualitative data set of interviews with and observations of correctional officers and residents from The Prison Projects’ prior in three prisons’ solitary confinement units
(including data from my previous USRP project), I have been examining staff interview data to examine the relationship dynamics between residents and correctional officers. My research is a part of a larger ongoing research initiative: Changing the Hole Mind: Living & Working in Solitary Confinement During Reform
Literature
I am interested in examining the nature of relationships between both groups to understand them through the lens of various types of interdependence since the concept came up a lot in my literature review
. Since a basic premise of social interdependence theory centers on the participants’ goals structure (which determines how they interact/relate with one another), I am digging through CO’s responses about their goals and perceptions of inmates’ goals and characteristics.
In the criminal justice field, research on relationships centers around power dynamics. Specifically how power can be perceived as legitimate in order to maintain order.
In the field, there also seems to be an emphasis on ensuring compliance, order, and obedience
Power is particularly important in the realm of correctional facilities because it plays a key role in prison society and in the interpersonal conflicts that arise between prisoners
The role of coercive power and predictability in literature implies that prison culture might exhibit a destructive kind of order in which violence is the norm
The Conflict field focuses on how power imbalances in relationships can be a source of conflict. A common theme is that conflict is especially likely when ambiguity exists about the nature of power.
Also, research in the field show that a system that has inconsistent status positions can escalate conflict
Research Gap
My research considers broad conflict theories in a specific context. Additionally, there is rarely an intersection between the criminal justice and conflict analysis disciplines. My research will demonstrate how conflict theory can be useful within the criminal justice discipline. Additionally, a gap that I am filling is understanding what specific dynamics of relationships between COs and inmates that are created from the structures of prisons that seem to be seeds to destructive conflicts that negatively impact both groups.
Research Question
Currently, I am examining staff perceptions about the relationships they hold with inmates.
I am using coding to classify if they are Positive or Negative according to the literature and get an idea if they create or prevent unhealthy dynamics that create conflict?
Findings
After taking to code and reflecting, and analyzing my codes, it has come to my attention that the majority of my findings were classified as negative indicators for relationship dynamics that potentially are seeds of conflict.
The main finding is the presence of negative social categorizations- This is a cognitive process by which we place individuals into social groups. This process can be destructive when the group has negative characteristics attributed to them.
Methods
After I received IRB access to all of the interview data, I began the process of coding. I am wrapping up my preliminary analysis of a smaller set of data. I will continue to use more data for qualitative data coding and analysis. I am using an open-coding strategy to code the interview data, and then returning to the data with a set of codes that serve the purpose of organizing, grouping, examining, and analyzing the qualitative data. After an additional round of coding is complete, I will refine my codes and organize them into code groups and themes that will set the stage for a deep analysis.
My next steps are to code the entire data set
My analysis and overall research will reveal insightful data and overall conclusions that describe and explain the structural influences on relationships.
Additionally, this knowledge will provide relevant interdisciplinary knowledge that can strengthen the conflict resolution framework and build a framework in the Criminal Justice field. These findings can also be used to provide recommendations to correctional facilities.
Thank you for taking the time to listen!